I graduated from Bir Zeit on the Hudson a little too early to remember Barry Soetoro a/k/a Barack Hussein Obama. But isn’t it more than a little curious that not a single one of the 25 members of the Columbia College Class of 1983 – allegedly Obama’s class – who lives in Israel remembers him?
What are Obama’s classmates in Israel up to? Quite a few,
like him, went straight to law school after finishing their
undergraduate degrees. One is a doctor, several are
engineers, and a few hold top jobs in finance. There’s an
architect in the group, a tour guide, a librarian, a speech
pathologist, an occupational therapist and a journalist.
Most are married with children (about three on average ), a
few are already grandparents, while others, who came to
parenting relatively late in life, are still chasing around
toddlers. Among the group are also two married couples who
began dating while in college.
They’re scattered around the country, but Beit Shemesh and
Ra’anana seem to be their preferred locales. Four live in
Jerusalem and its outskirts, three in Tel Aviv, two are up
north in Kfar Vradim, and two live over the Green Line in
the settlement of Ginot Shomron.
But here’s the thing: Not one of us remembers Barack Obama
– who transferred to Columbia after his sophomore year at
Occidental College in California – from our undergrad years,
nor do we know anyone else who does.
“If he wasn’t on my radar, he wasn’t on anyone’s radar,”
asserts Jamie Miller, a mother of five, who lives in Beit
Shemesh and remains active in the alumni association,
traveling back to New York every five years to attend
“I was a cheerleader, so I knew all the jocks,” says
Miller, who went to law school after college and today works
as a librarian and English teacher. “I was in the marching
band, I worked on the yearbook, and I was involved in
student government, so I knew everyone. But I never saw him
Sarah Graber Nehrer, a speech pathologist who moved with
her family from the United States to Rehovot last summer,
says she became curious about Obama even before his first
presidential run. “When he first came on the political
scene, back when he was running for the Senate, I was living
in Illinois, and I was like, ‘Wait, this guy went to school
with me,’” she explains. “But I had no recollection of him
whatsoever, and neither did anyone else I know, which I
found very strange.”
Compared with other American universities, Columbia, a
member of the prestigious Ivy League, is small. Its
graduating class in 1983 – including Columbia College for
men, Barnard College for women and the College of
Engineering – had fewer than 2,000 students. And since the
campus itself, located in the uptown Manhattan neighborhood
of Morningside Heights, is also quite small, the
opportunities to bump into your classmates and get to know
faces over a period of four years were abundant.
Yet another classmate, Michael Teplow, notes that someone
with presidential aspirations “wouldn’t be shy, but in fact,
quite gregarious,” which is why he, too, was surprised to
discover “when I first started flipping through my yearbook
looking for his picture that he wasn’t there, and I didn’t
remember him at all.” Like Obama, Teplow went onto law
school after he graduated Columbia. Today he lives in the
settlement of Ginot Shomron, from which he travels each
weekday to his law firm in Tel Aviv. Most of his practice is
in corporate law, but Teplow has also built up a pro-bono
side practice over the years representing Palestinians who
have served as informers for Israel’s security forces.
Another Tel Aviv corporate lawyer in the group is Norman
Menachem Feder, a senior partner in Caspi & Co., who
once clerked for the late Supreme Court Justice Menachem
Elon. “I spent most of my time at Columbia either in the
library or in the gym practicing for fencing, so if Obama
wasn’t hanging out in those places, I wouldn’t have seen
him,” he notes.
Teddy Weinberger moved to Israel 15 years ago with his
wife and former classmate Sarah Jane Ross, who works in
institutional sales at Excellence Nessuah investment house.
From their home in Givat Ze’ev, in the West Bank just north
of Jerusalem, where the couple live with their five
children, Weinberger continues to maintain close ties with
many of his old college buddies, and says he understands why
Obama may not have been on any of their radar. “He was a
transfer student living off campus and that made it possible
for him to keep such a low profile.”
What might be a fair comparison is to ask how many of them knew another famous Columbian from that era – George Stephanopoulos – who was a class ahead of them.
You don’t think Barry lied about going to Columbia, do you?